15 Years Removed
A former Wharton student considers his life after prison
Posted on Thursday, November 3, 2005 at 12:00 am
Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version
Send to a friend

On a rainy morning in late October, an unassuming man walks around Penn's campus marveling at how much it has changed. Seeing the campus for the first time in 15 years, he only recognizes bits and pieces of it, and it takes him some time to reorient himself. His memories take him back to his student days. Walking down Locust Walk, he says he feels young, like he is 19 again. He approaches his old dorm and sees what used to be called Van Pelt College House is now Gregory. "I still have property here, I don't know if they just destroyed it," he says looking at the entrance. "I left all my stuff ... I went home for Christmas and then went to trial and I've never been back."

This stocky black man with a carefully-trimmed beard, small glasses and a quiet demeanor could easily pass for an alumnus returning to campus. But Christopher Clemente never got his degree from Wharton. Instead, he has spent the better part of the last 15 years in prison, most of it in maximum security in upstate New York.

Christopher Clemente's saga has a starting date -- the night of January 9, 1990, when he found himself waiting for his older brother, who had just gotten out of the hospital from a gunshot wound. Clemente had spent many weekends that semester going back to Harlem. That's where he grew up, and, he says, the place in those years had an almost magnetic pull on him. Now, after spending his winter break there, he found himself in his brother's apartment on 112th Street near St. Nicholas Avenue, planning to catch the late-night Amtrak train back to Philadelphia for his spring semester at Penn.

He was sitting on the bed, talking to his brother's then-girlfriend, Leah Bundy, and suddenly heard a hard knock on the door and then an exchange:

Who is it?

It's the police, open the fucking door.

Is there a problem?

Yeah, there's a problem. Open the fucking door.

"And that's when everything went haywire," he remembers. After entering the apartment, the police found 214 vials of crack and a loaded MAC-11 machine gun, with an additional 2,000 vials and a loaded 9mm pistol reportedly thrown out of the window.

Why the police were at the apartment is disputed to this day. At the trial, the police officers claimed they were responding to a 911 call that reported gunshots in the building, though Clemente suspects it was really a set-up aimed at his brother, a heavy drug dealer at the time. That night, after the police raid, he found himself in New York's notorious Riker's Island prison complex, which sits on the East River between Queens and the Bronx, charged with 12 counts of drug and gun possession.

He would spend the next 11 weeks behind bars waiting for his $75,000 bail to be posted. During that time, he would be stabbed 16 times and wind up in critical condition, only to return to jail.

I think he should be allowed to come back and finish his degree. It's going to be difficult enough for him to find a job being a convicted felon.

Penn alum, Research

USA

I agree with the first comment. His situation is a tragedy and I believe that he should be able to finish the degree that he initially started. Although Christopher takes a very reserved and contemplative stance on his situation, my heart goes out to him and I commend his strength for all that he has had to suffer.

Current Student, undergraduate

Philadelphia, PA

I believe he has the right to be able to continue his education. He will need a strong educational background to overshadow his prison record. Good luck to him!!

Michelle Perry, Staff

Graduate School of Education

Clearly, this is a wonderful idea for a story. It's very, very well-written and it's fascinating. Any good journalist would jump at the opportunity to write about someone like Mr. Clemente.

Problem is, the story is recklessly biased. Instead of being an objective account of what Mr. Clemente went through, the reporter, at times, just lauds him with praise and paints him as a victim who was manhandled by "the system". All of that might be true, but it's not The Daily Pennsylvanian's job to make that determination. Does the newspaper have any proof that Mr. Clemente was innocent? If so, it's not in this story. It simply just takes what Mr. Clemente says and presents it as fact, backing it up with absurd statements like, "Part of the reason he's not angry is because he never allowed prison to demoralize or break him."

Please. The reporter wasn't in jail. He doesn't have a clue what Mr. Clemente went through. It's one thing if Mr. Clemente says that. It's quite another when a reporter decides to write that with no attribution to anyone.

Also, where's comment from the prosecutor or at least someone from the other side? Did the reporter try and speak with them? Did they decline? I have no idea.

This reporter is obviously a talented writer and storyteller. But he's still got quite a bit to learn about balanced reporting. This story would only be strengthened by the other side. By trying to artificially inflate Mr. Clemente, you've done him a disservice. The Daily Pennsylvanian has taken what could have been an incredibly well-done story on a very complex issue and simplified it.

Do better next time.

Jonathan Cribbs, Student

Owings, Md.

Has everyone forgotten the slightly longer version of "what happened"? It was just in the DP two years ago:

Link

I was a freshman when Clemente was arrested, and remember things a bit differently from the author's description. The evidence at the time seemed a little too coincidental to justify the "wrong place, wrong time" argument.

Still, glad to hear he has reformed himself and is now looking to put his life back together. Good luck to you Chris.

93 Alum

PA

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options